The Effective Prayer Of A Righteous Man

At the end of the book of James, there are a few verses that deal with prayer. The context is specifically prayer for someone who is sick, which seems like a lot of prayer from Christians in 21 century America. I used to take prayer requests from my students, sometimes publicly, so we could pray together, and some times privately, for my eyes only. And for God’s. The vast majority of the requests were for health issues.

But that’s beside the point, because, though that was James’s starting point, it’s not where he ended up. Instead he went to a general statement, then to a specific example. First the statement: “The effective prayer of a righteous man can accomplish much.”

What kind of “much” can prayer accomplish, James?

He answers this question with his example:

Elijah was a man with a nature like ours, and he prayed earnestly that it would not rain, and it did not rain on the earth for three years and six months. Then he prayed again, and the sky poured rain and the earth produced its fruit. (5:17-18)

I love the explanation of who Elijah was—a guy just like the rest of us. No super saint. He didn’t have angelic blood. He wasn’t special in any way. But he did have two things going for him. 1) His prayer was earnest. 2) He was righteous.

Whenever I read these verses, I think, I should be praying more. I mean—rain! We could use rain in Southern California.

But the point is not to pray for stuff just because I want to see stuff happen. Like the Dodgers winning the World Series or even something more practical like safety for a friend who is on a trip.

The key, I think, is in the “righteous” part. It reminds me of a verse in Psalm 37, one people love to quote: “Delight yourself in the LORD / And He will give you the desires of your heart.” (v 4)

Health-and-wealthers use that verse as a limitless credit card that God has to honor. Atheists use that verse as evidence that prayer “doesn’t work.”

But both groups are ignoring the first phrase: “delight yourself in the LORD.” That’s like being righteous. It’s essentially saying, enjoy God so much you would not want to be doing anything He doesn’t want you to do. So why would we ever pray for something we aren’t absolutely sure God wants?

In Elijah’s case, he prayed for no rain, then three plus years later, for rain, because God told him what to ask for. So he was sure. He knew what God wanted.

But why does God even bother? I mean, He can send the rain whether we ask or not, and usually does.

Again in Elijah’s situation, God accomplished several things. Elijah didn’t ask for these things in secret. People, particularly the king of Israel, knew why there was no rain. God was showing His power, His sovereignty to a disobedient and godless man. At the same time, Elijah’s prayer was serving as an example down through the ages to all who knew his story but who later read James’s commentary on it. And finally, God delights in involving His people in His work.

That’s believers today, just as much as it was believers in the first century.

My tendency, when I do get an idea of what God’s heart might be, is to pray too generally. When I was a kid it was, “Bless Grandpa and Grandma and all the aunts and uncles and cousins.” Today is more apt to be, “Work in the hearts of this people group or that one.”

So general. How would I ever know if that prayer is accomplishing much?

I’ve said before that the secret to prayer isn’t that it “works” at all, yet this verse in James and the one in the Psalms makes me think I’m only partly right there. I do think the biggest part of prayer is sharing God’s heart, pouring out my concerns to Him, and recommitting myself to trust Him in those circumstances. But praying for a judgment on a disobedient land? I would most certainly have to be convinced that’s what God wanted, just as Elijah was.

But that’s the point. Prayer moves me closer to God so that I actually do know what He wants. I know, for example, I am to love my neighbors. Any time I am not loving my neighbor, I can know for sure that I am not delighting in God, I am not praying as a righteous person who can expect to accomplish much.

In short, I don’t really need to worry whether or not my prayers are too general or too selfish or whatever. I simply need to pray so that I draw closer to God, so that I can be used by Him when He shows me what He wants me to pray for.

Published in: on October 5, 2018 at 5:54 pm  Comments (6)  
Tags: , , , ,


  1. Asking God to smite your country with drought (especially an agrarian society) did not lead to prosperity for Elijah. He almost starved himself and had to flee the monarch/s more than once.

    No way would Joel O. recommend that prayer.


    • I don’t know if you’ve ever heard old Joel preach, but he’s good at snatching phrases out of context and shoehorning them into his message so that they say what he wants them to say. And no one can accuse him of not preaching from the Bible. His followers all think he has a grasp on the truth that eludes others. I’m not sure why they don’t wonder why they have not become as rich as he, or even richer than they were when they first started attending his church.


      Liked by 1 person

      • I did on TV. Managed to stay awake too. Tried to read Your Best Life Now but as a chronic invalid forced to live with parents due to poverty his book was not only hollow but cruel. I threw it in the trash since propane had gone up.

        Liked by 1 person

        • I hear you, Rachel. People Like Joni Eareckson Tada have a lot more to say to all of us because it aligns with Scripture. What he says aligns with people’s wishful thinking, and it is cruel. It leads to people thinking God doesn’t come through on His promises. It robs people of true joy and peace and contentment. It debases suffering, when in fact, Christ ennobled it as a means of reflecting glory to God. Which would be more powerful—if God healed Joni’s broken back or if He gives her the grace to live and testify of Him, wheelchair bound for 50+ years? Both. I could get off on this! It’s such a misrepresentation of God’s word to distort the truth as these preachers do.



  2. Yes!!! This is the primary purpose of prayer. We want to grow closer to God, aligning our desires and requests with His will. Beautifully written, Becky!

    Liked by 2 people

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: