We Want To Be Cats, But We’re Sheep

Maybe I should have titled this post, “I want to be a cat, but I‘m just one of the sheep.” After all, should I be speaking for you?

I’m a little irritated right now at social media in general because The Powers That Be decide for the rest of us what they think we want, without asking us. Today it was Yahoo. Suddenly when I clicked on a new tab, I had a Yahoo search page pop up. I had to deactivate the Yahoo add-on to make it go away.

Sometime ago Facebook decided to speak for me—or more accurately, to think for me—by selecting what they deem to be my “Top Stories.” But they’re no different than Google+ who has determined what other G+ users I would most likely want to invite into my circles.

I think these social networking sites have taken their cue from cars that not only give you directions, but now park for you, change braking capacity under certain conditions, and even give you the hands off driving experience. For some years, those with alarm systems tell you (loudly) when something untoward approaches the vehicle.

The problem is, I’d rather think for myself. I’d rather do the driving because I like driving. I’m a responsible agent and shouldn’t need to be told to put on my seat belt. I like choosing my own routes instead of having a GPS tell me when to turn, and I think map reading is a good skill to have.

But more than that, I don’t want to be told who my friends should be on social media sites or what posts I should want to read. I want to think for myself.

I kind of assumed everyone else felt the same way (which is why I said “we” in the title, but I realize I am sort of playing the role of Facebook by doing so).

Perhaps this desire for independence is part of American Rugged Individualism we hear so much about— some of which I believe to be true. I mean, for people to pull up stakes and move across an ocean or to a foreign land where few people speak their language, they have to have a bit of individualism in them, I think.

And no matter how short or how long an American’s ancestors have been here, there is some value-passing that has preserved that individualistic spirit, that determination to go it alone against great odds.

However, I think there’s some of this independent spirit in all humankind. It’s not actually a good thing, either. It’s our desire, like small children who tell their parents they want to do “it” by themselves, to tell our Father that we can live life on our own.

In spite of this drive for independence, though, we—and this is the right pronoun this time—end up like sheep. Scripture says so. Besides Isaiah 53 that says, “All we like sheep have gone astray, each of us has turned to his own way” (v. 6a), Jeremiah paints a picture I think reflects our world today:

My people have become lost sheep;
Their shepherds have led them astray.
They have made them turn aside on the mountains;
They have gone along from mountain to hill
And have forgotten their resting place. (Jeremiah 50:6)

The passage originally referred to the Jewish people, but since all Scripture is profitable for doctrine, reproof, correction, instruction in righteousness, I don’t think it’s inappropriate to see us Gentiles in the same light—as sheep who are lost, who have shepherds leading them astray.

Now cats—they don’t let anyone lead. They don’t allow for herding. They scatter whithersoever they desire. But us sheep, we go where we ought not go just because everyone else is going there. We don’t always even notice where it is we’re going because we’re not paying all that much attention.

This is why we need a Good Shepherd. Cats, though, even if they had a Good Shepherd, would still go their own way. Eventually they’d end up high in a tree and too scared to climb down, too ornery to let anyone near enough to help them. Maybe being a sheep isn’t so bad. 😀

This post is an edited version of one that first appeared here in October 2011.

Published in: on August 1, 2016 at 6:22 pm  Comments (5)  
Tags: , , , , , ,


  1. Ha! Well said. I hear you about social media trying to do our thinking for us, It’s kind of scary.

    I have a car, pretty much on it’s last leg, but it has a transmission with a brain that allegedly adjusts to the driver. I’m telling you, that car and I have had more power struggles. It simply shifts when it wants to now and who cares if you’re going up a hill or trying to accelerate.

    I’m willing to be a sheep, but I draw the line at being led by the whims of some new fangled piece of technology. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • Amen to the not led by technology line. And about being sheep, it really is only good if we have the Good Shepherd. I thought about trying to reinforce that point, but I thought it would be too unwieldy. But that really is the only thing that sheep have going for us. Otherwise we will worse than cats—going aimlessly behind another sheep that is aimlessly going wherever his whim takes him. Not so different from having a car that drives us instead of us driving the car. I want Jesus to take the wheel! (Country music gets it right once in a while. 😉 )

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Love that verse from Jeremiah! Sign that a sheep is on the roam – forgot their resting place. I really needed to hear that today. I’m going to find that resting place.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Glad this post was what you needed, Ben. God’s grace that He directs us where we need. Oh, wait, isn’t that what the Good Shepherd always does? 🙂


      Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.