Do Nice People Go To Hell?

gas_craterIn the Facebook atheist/Christian group I’ve mentioned, one person asked, “Who here is going to hell?” The question was glib and the answers ranged from a Christian’s bemoaning the message in a picture of someone holding a sign that said “Going to hell and PROUD,” to a couple people who either echoed the sentiment or said they weren’t going because there was no such place. One person who embraced the idea that he’d be going to hell said, “The company will be amazing.”

In light of those comments and some of the questions that arose in another post here this week, I decided to revisit an article that originally appeared here in March 2011.
– – – –
What a question: Do nice people go to hell? There are a couple things we have to define, the first being “hell.”

In the New Testament, Jesus used the word we translate as “hell,” more than anyone else, which kind of shoots the ideas that some professing Christians have—that Jesus is loving and the Father, as the Old Testament reveals Him, is wrathful.

Even a casual reading of the gospels shows that Jesus made a clear statement about the judgment of those who reject Him. But how does He characterize this judgment? Sometimes as a place of darkness. Other times as a place where there will be “weeping and gnashing of teeth.” In one parable, Jesus says the evil servant will be assigned a place with the hypocrites. In Luke’s account of Jesus sending away those who claimed to know Him (“I never knew you”), He said they would be put out of the kingdom of God. And, yes, sometimes He made reference to a furnace or a place where there will be fire and brimstone.

Interesting that we camp on the image of fire, when all these other descriptions are also in Scripture. One pastor I recently heard believes we have formed our opinion of hell more from classic literature than from Scripture. For example, he pointed out that hell is the place created for Satan and his demons—spiritual beings. Consequently physical fire, it would seem, would have no effect on them.

What we know for sure about hell is that it is the just judgment God will assign to the wicked. “So it will be at the end of the age; the angels will come forth and take out the wicked from among the righteous” (Matt. 13:39).

So that brings up the question: Can nice people be “wicked”?

We know that there is none righteous, no not one. If we aren’t righteous—and what makes us “unrighteous” is that our own righteousness is nothing but contaminated tatters—then we are all, at our best, sinners.

Can sinners be nice people? Actually, yes. Before we were sinners we were made in God’s image. We have that about us still, though His glory is marred by our love of and commitment to ourselves. We are still a nice bunch … as long as I can be nice and receive credit for it. Or as long as I can be nice without going out of my way too much. Or as long as I can be nice and receive the same in return.

In short, we might look nice, but we come back to what Scripture says about our very best—it’s not pretty. And it most certainly is not efficacious for that which we need most—an answer to our sin condition.

Published in: on January 29, 2016 at 7:20 pm  Comments (5)  
Tags: , , ,


  1. It seems to me that when you have a mixed discussion thread about such a topic as hell, there will be scoffers who speak a little more boldly just to get a rise out of people. In one to one, face to face conversations though, explaining God’s judgment to people has been more helpful in my experience. When you lay out God’s holiness and justice, and point people to God’s law and that little conscience they’ve been ignoring, things begin to make sense. A good God doesn’t overlook evil deeds–he makes things right. And he even gives repeat offenders abundant grace while he waits for them to repent and receive the undeserved gift of his only son, Jesus Christ.

    Liked by 3 people

  2. It’s a great assessment: “as long as I can be nice and receive credit for it. Or as long as I can be nice without going out of my way too much. Or as long as I can be nice and receive the same in return.”
    That first one above all! Do we EVER do something good and selfless without (if even just a tiny bit) to be recognized for it? That tiny bit becomes everything when we realize no one notices.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Oops…without WANTING to be recognized…


  4. Good one, Becky. When I helped someone at great cost to myself, I was discouraged that I wasn’t even thanked. Even giving anonymously doesn’t work – I still like the good feeling
    I get. 🙂 It is impossible to be completely selfless, it seems. Only Jesus is.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. That’s kind of a pet peeve of mine, when people think they’re so saintly that they should be good enough to get into heaven just because they think they’re ‘nice’.

    I have a saying ‘good people do bad things.’. I don’t mean that good people are ones that always go around hurting others, I mean that even the best people will act like jerks, or say and do horrible things when pushed to their emotional limits. Sometimes I think the people shouting that they are too good to deserve hell are the ones that act the worst, because they think they are doing nothing wrong. It’s harder to change for the better when someone thinks there’s little to be changed. I know that in the church there is a lot of reflection on how to be more loving and follow Christ better, and therefore things are getting better.

    If anyone thinks they are such perfectly kind people, I’m sure they would see things differently if they could see how they’ve acted when they were ‘young and foolish’, or having a bad day, or trying to get someone to see their side of an argument.


Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: